When I first received the package of Mr. McGroovy’s Box Rivets I thought to myself “what a clever idea.” Hours of fun with the kids building cool projects to play with and play in.
I really wanted my trial to be successful, because I do think that
the idea of this product is a good one, and it seems to offer an
inexpensive solution to the building of various types of playthings,
from lemonade stands to playhouses to forts.
BUT- I had much different results than I had hoped for.
It’s not that the rivets don’t work- they do. They also hold rather
well. However, as a mom who is often alone with the kids and prefers an
easy-to-manage project, I was not pleased.
To start with, you must access the Mr. McGroovy’s web site
to get plans. That was easy enough. But they do not provide any pre-cut
parts (which would be very helpful) or pre-fab projects for you to
purchase and construct.
Instead you have to seek out your own cardboard boxes- BIG cardboard boxes. You need to find appliance (refrigerator, washer) sized boxes, and multiples for most of the plans.
Just trying to take my kids (age 3 and 5) with me to Home Depot to
pick the boxes up, and to even think about trying to load them into my
mini-van (even broken down, they take up a lot of space) was a daunting
task for this less than patient mom.
Now, once you manage to pick up boxes, you need to follow the
“blueprints”- measuring and cutting (and let me tell you, box cutters
and small children do not mix!) to get the pieces set up to fit
together.
No problem for some, but I found the plans a little hard to follow
and the preparation excessively time consuming. By this point you are still not even close to assembly.
Now in all fairness, it is officially confession time. I got
frustrated with the project and gave up on the cutting and assembling
of one of the McGroovy plans.
Instead, I used a kit from Bed Bath and Beyond that I already had at
home for a cardboard lemonade stand so that I could test these rivets
out before my kids were in college.
Oh, and did I mention the need for power tools?
Yup, the directions require you to pre-drill holes for the rivets to pass through. Now I am a fairly handy
girl and my husband has a garage full of tools (some of which I know
how to use, like the drill) that I can borrow, but I imagine that other
moms (and dads) may not be so fortunate in that department.
You really do need to pre-drill or punch a hole through the
cardboard- they won’t just poke through otherwise. Once you have your
holes drilled, the rivets themselves are very easy to use. They snap
together quite easily, without much force necessary (though my 5 year
old was not strong enough to be able to help).
Once my project was assembled, it did hold together fairly well. The
length of the rivets do allow for some wiggle (i.e.- the rivet was not
super snug if I only had 2 layers of cardboard, but it also is made to
accommodate more thickness if needed), but this was not a big deal.
Disassembly (i.e.- taking apart the rivets to re-use) was not as
easy as snapping the rivets together, because they do fit together so
securely. You have to use a special tool to pull them apart (which I
did receive with the rivets).
This was a bit of a pain but not bad, and it was nice to have a product that you can re-use.
The long and short of it for me is that the concept of the rivets
themselves is pretty cool. If you have time, the right tools, and very
patient children, then I could recommend this product for you.
However- time, tools, and patience are key (as is the availability
of large cardboard boxes), and in my household it just didn’t work out
well.
Even with the lemonade stand I had purchased, it took a long time
for assembly, and the kids were not able to help much. I got really
tired of the rousing chorus of “mommy is it ready to paint yet?” The
time and effort did not come close to balancing out the reward with
this project.